Yes, this is ugly. Both by the standards of common legibility and pleasantness and in contrast to the menus featured so far on this site. But this menu is a perfect reflection of the establishment, Shopsins in New York, the eclectic diner of the eccentric Kenny Shopsin. Once an eleven-page menu featuring over 900 items, the selection has been pared down to fit in a single, double-sided sheet. And fit snugly it does. There isn’t a single bit of white space where your eye can rest, with every nook and cranny filled either with menu items or with really, really bad photography. If you wonder who could design such a sadistic menu you would have to look no further than Shopsin himself: “Shopsin’s daughter, Tamara,” explains a Saveur article, “once admitted that the worst thing she had ever done was teach her father how to use Adobe InDesign. She didn’t expect him to exploit the text-squeeze function to such an extent.” Enjoy. Or not.
Phenomenally wretched. A true example of everything NOT to do in menu design. I think there is a way to be eccentric without having to ruin the person's ability to actually figure out what they'd like to order.
I'm all for "eclectic" but this is probably the worst menu design I've ever seen, and I've seen too many to count. It's not cute or fun, or even "true to the restaurant." It's just horrid and extremely difficult to read.
Try scanning any section of this menu for something you'd like to eat, especially the large blocks of text with white backgrounds. You have to read every single line if you want to consider your meal options.
There's no art here, and design is debatable. Remind me again why this is listed on Art of the Menu?
Is this a joke?
Hahaha...I hear what you all are saying. It kind of gives you a small seizure when you're trying to order, especially when I've seen someone get kicked out for taking to long to order! However, I'm glad to see the menu here. This menu, believe it or not, totally adds to the experience which is Shopsins. Go eat at the restaurant yourself (if you can get a table), or better yet, watch this documentary, eat there, then tell me what you think about the menu.
P.S. I recommend the "Blisters on My Sister"
Ack! My eyes are burning!
Actually, the design is good, even if it's not something you probably saw in a type or design class in undergrad.
It's distinct (which really only matters for competitions or studies like this forum), hierarchy and division of choice is mostly clear, type size is readable, the "grid" helps, it isn't precious or fussy or " cute" (which is were most designers would want this to go toward), it's probably a fair representation of the restaurant, you actually want to read the entire thing because you know there is some wack-ass sandwich somewhere in there. I don't think the point of a menu is to have "white space for your eye to rest." And, considering the quantity of offerings, this output is much more difficult to execute, and was probably under an overly designed designer's budget.
Come on. This is hilarious. I would enjoy the entertainment if I ate here. This is part of it! Why does everything have to be so perfect, designers? It gets a bit sickening after a while.
Love it. I can't imagine going to Shopsin's and not seeing this menu. Fits the place perfectly.
Tons of typos... as for the design, i've never been to Shopsin's so i really can't judge the approach.
This design is as honest as it comes. Most of us would probably design it into an unrecognizable myth or something that "perfects" what Shopsin would do "if he only knew how." All that said, it's an ugly menu. No lie.
Bottom line: Unreadable. Say what you want about the experience or how it matches up. I'll take your word for it. I can't read it. I doubt anyone really can.
I can't read it. I doubt anyone really can.
...and yet, somehow people still manage to order. Amazing!
Thanks for this interesting article. I hope you post more articles soon, I plan to share this.
Is it just me, or does the guy with the beverage at the top look like Alex from A Clockwork Orange?
Really punk, I like it.
Actually, none of you thought how Shopsin came with the idea. It looks to me the man reads a lot of newspaper ads and his menu looks so much like free ads page of any newspaper in the world. (At least on my side of world)
Except for color, newspapers avoid using so much color but I guess that was his "touch-up" :)
Unreadable? Oh, well, the same is with the ads yet when you're searching for a job or to buy something, you will have the patience to do it, why not when eating at Shopsins :)
@Lauren Dickens: That's my exact same thought. It's actually ALL i can see in the menu!
Art of the Menu, is a division of UnderConsideration, cataloguing the underrated creativity of menus from around the world.
Art of the Menu uses Typekit to render Proxima Nova by Mark Simonson and Adelle by Type Together.
Art of the Menu is run with Six Apart’s MovableType 6.1.1
All comments, ideas and thoughts on Art of the Menu are property of their authors; reproduction without the author’s or Art of the Menu’s permission is strictly prohibited
UnderConsideration is a graphic design enterprise that runs a network of blogs, publishes books, organizes live events and judged competitions, and designs for clients.
Brand New / Displaying opinions and focusing solely on corporate and brand identity work.
FPO (For Print Only) / Celebrating the reality that print is not dead by showcasing the most compelling printed projects.
Quipsologies / Chronicling the most curious, creative, and notable projects, stories, and events of the graphic design industry on a daily basis.
Speak Up (2002 – 2009) / Discussing, and looking for, what is relevant in, and the relevance of, graphic design. Archives Only.
Word It (2003 – 2010) / Encouraging creative diversity in the community through monthly, one-word challenges. Archives Only.
Brand New Classroom (2010 – 2011) / Providing a space for critique and opinions on student identity workArchives Only.
Department of Design / Designing corporate and brand identities and full development of printed and digital matter for clients.
The 2010 Brand New Awards / 2011, self-published.
Flaunt: Designing effective, compelling and memorable portfolios of creative work / 2010, self-published.
Events & Judged Competitions
Brand New Conference / A one-day event on the development of corporate and brand identity projects by some of today’s most active and influential practitioners from around the world.
Brand New Awards / Celebrating the best identity work produced around the world.
FPO Awards / Celebrating the best print work from around the world.
Graphic Design, Referenced: A Visual Guide to the Language, Applications, and History of Graphic Design / 2009, Rockport.
Women of Design: Influence and Inspiration from the Original Trailblazers to the New Groundbreakers / 2008, HOW Books.
The Word It Book: Speak Up Presents a Gallery of Interpreted Words / 2007, HOW Books.