Opinions on corporate and brand identity work.

A division of UnderConsideration.








Share ›

New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
 

before

after

Noted Mar. 8, 2017 by Armin

Industry / Sports Tags /

About

Ontario Soccer was founded in 1901 and is one of the oldest and largest sport organizations in Canada. Ontario Soccer provides leadership and support for the advancement of soccer in collaboration and cooperation with our membership, partners and other stakeholders by providing exceptional and sustainable programs and services. The Association is made up of 21 District Offices and several Associate Members namely regional and provincial leagues. The District’s membership are the more than 600 Youth Clubs and Senior Clubs across Ontario.”

Design by

Logo and Identity: Brandfire (Markham, Ontario)
Sub-brands, signage, and implementation: In-house

Related links

Ontario Soccer press release

Relevant quote
Combining modern and sleek design elements, with a nod to the organization’s long-standing heritage, the primary logo is the new face of Ontario Soccer.

The five outer rings create a contemporary soccer ball shape, representing Ontario Soccer’s five most important stakeholder groups: Players, Coaches, Match Officials, Volunteers and Administrators.

The inner three shapes, celebrating the mantra of Play, Inspire and Unite, create an Ontario trillium at the very centre of the mark.

Ontario Soccer press release

Images (opinion after)
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Logo.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Logo explanation.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Tagline explanation.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Sub-brands.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Identity elements.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Step and repeat pattern.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
Brand guidelines cover.
New Logo and Identity for Ontario Soccer by Brandfire and In-house
PowerPoint template cover.
Brand video.
Opinion

The old logo wasn’t technically good in any way — wrong font, wrong letterspacing, wrong sizing, clip-art-y graphics, etc. — but, somehow, it felt like a charming, connected soccer community. The new logo feels like a heavy marketization of the organization, trying very hard to make it into something super extra exciting, which is a fine and respectable ambition but the resulting logo and the accompanying rationalization is too much. If you love swooshes, meet your new best friend, otherwise this is pretty hard to look at, with five swooshes coming together around a swoosh-based trillium (which is a commonly used symbol for Ontario). It’s oddly aggressive when it doesn’t need to be — it’s too sharp — and the gradient doesn’t add anything. The wordmark is okay on its own but has no visual relationship to the icon and the typography in the tagline has no relationship with either. There is a lack of cohesiveness and it’s a feeling enhanced by the multiple pieces of the icon, which feels like it might fall apart at any second, like if you kicked a soccer ball through a Chihuly sculpture. The few applications shown don’t get much better unless, again, you love swooshes or really miss the DirecTV logo. Overall, not a very pleasant redesign but, ultimately, it does at least bring it aesthetically into the twenty-first century.

Thanks to Mark Guilherme for the tip.

Your opinion…

On Icon


Total

On Wordmark


Total

On Application


Total

Comments


Logo Before & After
Sample Application

Share ›

Spotted Around the web

New Logo for Flexera

New Logo for Flexera
 
Spotted Aug. 15, 2017

New Icon for iOS App Store

New Icon for iOS App Store
 
Spotted Aug. 15, 2017

Pinned Recent, Big Stories

New Logo for NASCAR

New Logo for NASCAR
 
Posted Jan. 4, 2017

Curated Good for Stencils

New Logo for WSP by Sid Lee

New Logo for WSP by Sid Lee
 
Spotted May. 16, 2017