Opinions on corporate and brand identity work.

A division of UnderConsideration.








Share ›

New Logo for SFMTA
 

before

after

Noted May. 3, 2018 by Armin

Industry / Government Tags /

About

“Established by voter proposition in 1999, the SFMTA (San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency), a department of the City and County of San Francisco, oversees Muni (the historic Municipal Railway), parking and traffic, bicycling, walking and taxis. Over one million people get around San Francisco and rely on us to ensure safe and reliable travel.”

Design by

N/A

Related links

SFMTA press release
Brand New post from 2012

Relevant quote
First, never fear, this new logo will exist alongside the beloved Muni “worm” logo. The new SFMTA logo has been carefully designed to bring together the primary two elements of the agency: Muni and the former Department of Parking and Traffic. The city’s transit system will still be Muni and its look will not change.

From the outset, we knew this new SFMTA brand would have to balance several needs. It would have to better connect us as an agency and make us easily identifiable to the public. It was also important that a new brand convey the SFMTA’s proud heritage as the operator of the oldest publicly owned transit agency in the country.

With all this in mind, we tested several logo designs with the public. And we heard that we should embrace the “M” logo. Just as “Muni” is short for San Francisco Municipal Railway, this “M” would stand for the “municipal” in the agency name. The letter part of the logo also pays homage to the Muni “worm” logo designed by Walter Landor in 1977. It’s funky and uniquely San Francisco. It also helps that “M” is frequently used in other large cities to symbolize transit services.

SFMTA press release

Images (opinion after)
New Logo for SFMTA
Logo, horizontal.
New Logo for SFMTA
Logo, vertical.
Opinion

The old logo, the result of a contest, was decent, with a transportation-y vibe of lanes/paths crossing and a peppy color palette but, perhaps, not San Francisco enough. When it comes to transportation and San Francisco there is probably no more iconic logo than the Muni’s “worm” logo, designed by Walter Landor in the 1970s. Adopting that logo’s “M” as the key identifier for the larger agency is a smart way to create an instant connection to what the agency does — although now, the agency might just come across as the one that handles buses but I think the addition of the more bureaucratic-looking “SFMTA” wordmark makes it feel more like a bigger city entity. The “M” looks great on its own and sits neatly in the blue square — on its own, it’s like a trippy face smiling at you. The gray rectangle with the “SFMTA” is as dry as it gets but it tempers the playfulness of the “M”. Overall, and not being a San Francisco resident, I don’t know if this logo creates more confusion or solves the issue of clarifying who SFMTA is and what it does.

Thanks to Rafal Dudziec for the tip.

Your opinion…

On Logo


Total
See what else happened on Brand New each year since publication began in 2006

Comments


Logo Before & After

Share ›

Spotted Around the web

New Logo for Wirecutter

New Logo for Wirecutter
 
Spotted Jun. 3, 2020

Pinned Recent, Big Stories


Curated THE ITALIC JOB

New Logo for Lifetime

New Logo for Lifetime
 
Posted Mar. 26, 2020
 
 

About

Brand New, is a division of UnderConsideration, displaying opinions, and focusing solely, on corporate and brand identity work. More…

UnderConsideration is a graphic design firm generating its own projects, initiatives, and content while taking on limited client work. Run by Bryony Gomez-Palacio and Armin Vit in Bloomington, IN.

Many Thanks to our Advertisers

When choosing between competing products and services, please consider our advertisers, who help support Brand New.

Typography

Brand New uses Mercury Text ScreenSmart and Operator ScreenSmart from Hoefler & Co.

Webfonts by Hoefler & Co.

Join our Mailing List